This blog is about the article “Why Doctors Hate Their Computers” in the New Yorker by Atul Gawande. The article talks about the complications the doctors encountered after upgrading the electronic medical record system they used to Epic.
There were some tensions that caused the system to make doctors’ lives harder than easier. It became more political than technical. Staff and doctors had different views on what should be included. Now they added more questions that are “field required” that doctors used to skip that added more time to finish. Another tension was that different doctors can modify a patients profile. Three people will list the same diagnostic in different ways. Some will just list what is required just so the system does not alert them, some are not useful to the doctors who need to know a specific diagnosis.
I agree with Gregg Meyer. He said that “But we think of this as a system for us and it’s not,” “It is for the patients.” After reading the article, it really seems like it was not made for doctors but for the patients. It was made in a way that every patient should have a record on every required field which made it harder for the doctors to do their work. The system was also used so that patients can log into it to look up their lab results, remind them of the medications they are supposed to take and read the doctors note to the patients. There are more patients than doctors so I think Epic was made so that the patients can easily access it.
This article was long but it was interesting to read. As someone who is trying to work on the field of software development, I found it interesting how important it was to know the customers we are building it for. I think for us developers, it is easy to make a system that we could understand and use relatively easy, but without the perspective of the end user or the real customer for these systems, it might not be the same scenario for them. There are still a lot of people who are not tech savvy. This lesson of implementation of this system does not only apply to Electronic Medical records systems. For example, there is a show called Silicon Valley, where they made this software for a middle-out compression solution. It was the talk of the town. It was the fastest algorithm at the time. The developer asked his friends (other developers) to look at the finished product, and they all liked it. Then the time came when they were trying to release the software. They had ordinary people testing the software and they couldn’t understand how to use it and what it does. They had to teach them for weeks and there were only a couple testers who learned from it. Moral of the story was the same in the article, for us developers, we have to pretend that we do not know anything about our system sometimes and see if it is friendly enough for others.
From the blog cs-wsu – Computer Science by csrenz and used with permission of the author. All other rights reserved by the author.